// Comparison

Introduction à la cyberstratégie vs Technopolitique: Which Should You Read?

Two cybersecurity books on Strategy, compared honestly: who each is for, what each does best, and which to read first.

Intermediate
3/52015
Introduction à la cyberstratégie

Olivier Kempf

A foundational French introduction to cyberstrategy — treating cyberspace as a domain of strategic thought — by a former officer and strategy scholar.

Intermediate
4/52024
Technopolitique

Comment la technologie fait de nous des soldats

Asma Mhalla

A sharp, current essay on how digital technology, AI and platform power have turned citizens into actors in a permanent informational and geopolitical conflict, by a prominent French tech-politics scholar.

Read this if

Strategy students and analysts who want a structured French-language introduction to thinking about cyberspace strategically, in the Economica strategic-studies tradition.
Readers who want a contemporary French framing of the politics of technology — surveillance, AI, platform power, information warfare — at the intersection of geopolitics and daily life.

Skip this if

Technical readers or those wanting current operational detail; it's an academic strategic introduction, and even the 2015 edition predates much recent history.
Readers wanting technical or security how-to; it's a political essay and big-picture argument, not a practitioner's text.

Key takeaways

  • A clear French-language entry point to cyberspace as a strategic domain.
  • Sits in the academic strategic-studies tradition (Economica), complementing Boyer's more operational pair.
  • The second edition (2015) adds chapters on French cyberstrategy; read for the framework, not current events.
  • A very current (2024) French framing of technology as a domain of permanent geopolitical and informational conflict.
  • Mhalla is a widely-followed voice on tech politics — the argument is sharp and contemporary.
  • Big-picture and political: read for the framing of AI/platform power, not for technique.

How they compare

We rate Technopolitique higher (4/5 against 3/5 for Introduction à la cyberstratégie). For most readers, that means Technopolitique is the primary pick and Introduction à la cyberstratégie is a useful follow-up.

Both books target intermediate-level readers, so the choice is about topic, not difficulty.

Introduction à la cyberstratégie and Technopolitique both cover Strategy, Geopolitics, so reading them in sequence reinforces the same material from different angles.

Keep reading

Related topics