// Comparison

La cyberstratégie russe vs Technopolitique: Which Should You Read?

Two cybersecurity books on Geopolitics, compared honestly: who each is for, what each does best, and which to read first.

Intermediate
3/52013
La cyberstratégie russe

Yannick Harrel

A focused study of Russia's approach to cyberspace — doctrine, actors and information warfare — one of the few French-language books dedicated to a single state's cyberstrategy.

Intermediate
4/52024
Technopolitique

Comment la technologie fait de nous des soldats

Asma Mhalla

A sharp, current essay on how digital technology, AI and platform power have turned citizens into actors in a permanent informational and geopolitical conflict, by a prominent French tech-politics scholar.

Read this if

Analysts and strategy readers who want to understand Russian cyber doctrine and information operations specifically, with a French/European framing.
Readers who want a contemporary French framing of the politics of technology — surveillance, AI, platform power, information warfare — at the intersection of geopolitics and daily life.

Skip this if

Readers wanting technical detail or current events; it's a 2013 strategic study, so it predates much of the last decade of Russian cyber activity.
Readers wanting technical or security how-to; it's a political essay and big-picture argument, not a practitioner's text.

Key takeaways

  • A rare French-language deep dive into a single nation's cyberstrategy — Russia's.
  • Useful for the doctrinal and information-warfare framing that later events (2016, Ukraine) made famous.
  • From 2013: foundational context, but pair with newer reporting (e.g. Sandworm) for events since.
  • A very current (2024) French framing of technology as a domain of permanent geopolitical and informational conflict.
  • Mhalla is a widely-followed voice on tech politics — the argument is sharp and contemporary.
  • Big-picture and political: read for the framing of AI/platform power, not for technique.

How they compare

We rate Technopolitique higher (4/5 against 3/5 for La cyberstratégie russe). For most readers, that means Technopolitique is the primary pick and La cyberstratégie russe is a useful follow-up.

Both books target intermediate-level readers, so the choice is about topic, not difficulty.

La cyberstratégie russe and Technopolitique both cover Geopolitics, Strategy, so reading them in sequence reinforces the same material from different angles.

Keep reading

Related topics